|
MICHIGAN UNITED CONSERVATION CLUBS
Annual Convention
June 23 - 24, 2007
Quality Inns & Suites
Sault Ste. Marie, Michigan
Pre-Convention Board Meeting – June 23, 2007
President Meixner called the meeting to order at 8:00
a.m.
President Meixner asked for a motion to go into closed session
with the invitation to MUCC staff to remain in the room.
Van Loon (Demos) supports
John Robertson presented the Executive Director search process
to the board.
President Meixner informed the members of the board of the
Executive Committee recommendation of Dennis Muchmore as the new MUCC
Executive Director.
Paul Rose presented information on Mr. Muchmore’s
background.
Steve Bartz asked for a motion to accept Dennis Muchmore as
the new Executive Director for the contract term of 2.5 years.
B. Levey (Kensinger) supports
Motion adopted unanimously
Bill Furtaw asked for a motion to come out of closed
session.
D. Levey (Pachy) supports
Affiliation of five (5) new clubs, Pat Klott, Chair
-
Lapeer County Pheasants Forever, MUCC Dist. 9, 350 total
club members
-
St. Mary's River Sportsman's Club, MUCC Dist. 18, 10
total club members
-
U.P. Trapper's Assoc., MUCC Dist. 3, 175 total
members
-
Michigan Bowhunters Dist. 7, MUCC Dist. 1, 221 total
members
-
Michigan Bowhunters Dist. 4, MUCC Dist. 5, 282
total members
President Meixner asked for a motion to adjourn the
pre-convention meeting
Yeager (Supina) moved to adjourn the pre-convention meeting
The Board of Directors pre-convention meeting adjourned at 8:59
a.m.
MICHIGAN UNITED CONSERVATION CLUBS
Annual Convention
Quality Inns & Suites
Sault Ste. Marie, Michigan
Saturday, June 23, 2007
Call to order and Welcome – of the 70th
annual meeting was made at 9:04 a.m. by President Meixner
Pledge of Allegiance – was led by Statewide Vice
President Dave Mortimer
Conservation Pledge - was led by Statewide Vice
President Bill Krepps
Invocation – was given by Immediate Past President Fran
Yeager
Moment of Silence – was led by President Meixner in
honor of the U.S. military men and women serving on foreign soil
Orders of the day: - Bruce Levey, Parliamentarian
RULES
•
A. ROBERT’S RULES OF ORDER SHALL BE THE AUTHORITY ON CONVENTION
PROCEDURE.
B. ALL VOTING WILL BE BY VOICE UNLESS OTHERWISE
REQUIRED. A SHOW OF HANDS OR A ROLL CALL VOTE MAY BE ORDERED BY THE CHAIR FOR
ACCURACY.
C. ONLY VOTING DELEGATES MAY BE SEATED IN THE DELEGATES VOTING
SECTION.
D. ONLY REGISTERED VOTING DELEGATES MAY VOTE OR MAKE/SUPPORT
MOTIONS.
E. VOTING DELEGATES MUST WEAR BLUE BADGES, AND
CARRY VOTING CARDS INDICATING THE NUMBER OF VOTES CARRIED.
F. RESOLUTIONS TO CHANGE THE BYLAWS REQUIRE A 2/3 VOTE.
G. RESOLUTIONS TO CHANGE STATE OR FEDERAL LAW REQUIRE A 2/3
VOTE.
AMENDMENTS •
LENGTHY AMENDMENTS (MORE THAN A FEW WORDS, TYPOS OR SIMPLE
EDITORIAL CORRECTIONS
EXCEPTED) SHOULD BE SUBMITTED ON THE “RESOLUTIONS AMENDMENT
FORM” (AVAILABLE
AT THE ANNUAL MEETING) WITH A COPY, OR THE ORIGINAL, SUBMITTED
TO THE
RECORDING SECRETARY. THE AMENDED RESOLUTION WILL THEN BE
DISPLAYED ON A SCREEN
FOR ALL TO REVIEW.
PROCEDURE FOR TESTIMONY ON RESOLUTIONS •
IN ORDER TO ENSURE SUFFICIENT TIME FOR A FULL EXPLORATION OF
EACH RESOLUTION
BEFORE THE 2007 ANNUAL CONVENTION, THE FOLLOWING
PROCEDURE WILL BE IMPLEMENTED:
1. THE SPONSOR OR SPONSORING CLUB OF A RESOLUTION HAS FIVE
MINUTES TO EXPLAIN THE RESOLUTION AND ADVOCATE FOR ITS PASSAGE.
2. TWO MICROPHONES, DESIGNATED SUPPORT OR
OPPOSED, WILL BE AVAILABLE. SPEAKERS MUST USE ONE TO BE RECOGNIZED FOR
DISCUSSION AND THEY WILL SPEAK ALTERNATELY. PLEASE USE THE APPROPRIATE
MICROPHONE FOR YOUR POSITION (SUPPORT OR OPPOSE) ON THE ISSUE.
3. ALL MEMBERS HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY, IF SO INTERESTED, TO SPEAK
FOR TWO MINUTES FOR OR AGAINST A RESOLUTION.
4. MEMBERS MAY TESTIFY TWO TIMES ON A RESOLUTION. A TWO-THIRDS
VOTE OF THE DELEGATES IS REQUIRED FOR A PERSON TO TESTIFY MORE THAN TWO
TIMES.
5. MUCC’S PARLIAMENTARIAN (OR THEIR AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE)
WILL KEEP TRACK OF THE TIME OF EACH TESTIFIER TO ENSURE THE TIME LIMITS ARE
NOT EXCEEDED.
6. MEMBERS ARE ENCOURAGED TO NOT DUPLICATE TESTIMONY AND TO
STRUCTURE THEIR TESTIMONY TO INCREASE THE UNDERSTANDING OF THE CONVENTION
AUDIENCE ON THE ISSUE.
7. A MOTION, AND A SECOND, TO BRING A RESOLUTION TO THE FLOOR
WILL NOT REQUIRE USE OF THE MICROPHONES. PLEASE STATE YOUR NAME
CLEARLY.
8. SPEAKERS MUST IDENTIFY THEMSELVES WITH THEIR NAME, CLUB NAME
OR MUCC TITLE EACH TIME THEY USE THE MICROPHONE FOR ACCURATE RECORDING BY THE
RECORDING SECRETARY.
9. IF NO ONE IS AT THE OPPOSITE MICROPHONE THE CHAIR MAY
SUGGEST A VOTE TO BE TAKEN.
Bruce Levey asked for a motion to accept the Orders of the
Day as read
Van Loon (Kensinger) supports
Opening Remarks:
President Meixner provided voting instruction on the color
coded delegate voting cards.
President Meixner introduced Brenda Reich, the Recording
Secretary; Statewide Vice Presidents Bill Krepps and Dave Mortimer, Donna
Stine as the Interim Executive Director, and Fran Yeager, filling in for
Statewide Vice President, Dan Radloff.
President Meixner appointed Bruce Levey as the official
parliamentarian, and Amanda Burmeister as assistant parliamentarian. Ms.
Burmeister has graciously offered her time to assist in following the Roberts
Rules of Order over the course of the convention. Ms. Burmeister is working
towards her degree in government and is currently a senior at Lake State
University, Sault Ste. Marie, Michigan
President Meixner welcomed and introduced the past presidents
in attendance: Bud Slingerlend, Wendy Briggs, Art Dittmar, Bob Laich, Danny
Delisle, Fran Yeager and Russ Reister
President Meixner announced that Dennis Muchmore has been
appointed as the new MUCC Executive Director.
Report of the Credentials Committee:
Mary Ann McCormack announced there were sufficient delegates
duly registered with the Credential Committee to constitute a quorum.
Report of the Nominations Committee:
Fran Yeager asked for a motion to bring the nominations to
the floor
Norma Hays-Walkley (Kensinger) supports
Presidential nominations: George Cullers and Don Meixner (Mr.
Cullers declined)
Fran Yeager asked for a motion to close the presidential
nominations
Dittmar (Kensinger) supports
Statewide Vice President nominations: Bill Krepps, Dan Radloff,
Dawn Levey, and Al Weaver
Fran Yeager asked for a motion to close the statewide vice
presidents nominations
Al Pachy (Kensinger) supports
Regional I Vice President nominations: Jay Maki
Fran Yeager asked for a motion to close the region I vice
president nominations
Kensinger (Demos) supports
Regional II Vice President Nominations: Pete Demos
Fran Yeager asked for a motion to close the region II vice
president nominations
Kensinger (B. Levey) supports
Regional III Vice President Nominations: Paul Earl
Fran Yeager asked for a motion to close the region III vice
president nominations
Kensinger (B. Levey) supports
Regional IV Vice President Nominations: Jim Van Loon, Jack
Marko
Fran Yeager asked for a motion to close the region IV vice
president nominations
Supina (Demos) supports
Treasurer nominations: Paul Rose
Fran Yeager asked for a motion to close the treasurer
nominations
Furtaw (Kensinger) supports
Director-at-Large nominations: (Eldon Montross declined)
-
Region I: Jack Lehto, and George Lindquist
-
Region II: Marlin Bussey and Jim Chaskey
-
Region III: Mary Ann McCormack, Norma Hays-Walkley,
Bruce Levey, and Alan Kasdorf
-
Region IV: Dale Reeves, Al Hare, and Paul
Farrell
Fran Yeager asked for a motion to close the
director-at-large nominations
J. Finnerty (D. Levey) supports
Michigan Department of Environmental Quality
Report
Steve Chester, MDEQ Director
Michigan Department of Natural Resources Report
Jim Ekdahl, Upper Peninsula Field Representative (on behalf of
Director Humphries)
A motion was asked to have a letter crafted over the weekend
to send to the legislators supporting the DNR license fee increase.
The Board was asked to send the letters to the state
legislators written in their personal handwriting
Donna Stine reported that three action letters have been sent
out on this issue and information had been posted on the MUCC website.
Motion – withdrawn
Report of the Executive Director, Interim Director Donna
Stine
Donna introduced Marc Smith, NWF Regional Field Representative
(replacing Brian Preston) and Adam Star, from Show Span and a new producer for
MOOD. Ms. Stine introduced MUCC policy staff members Erin McDonough, Jason
Dinsmore, and April Bennett; Tony Hansen, Editor of Michigan Out-of-Doors;
Linn Duling and Jim Grant, MUCC Field Coordinators. A special thank you to
Brenda Reich our Executive Assistant for all of her work in making this
convention a success. Please let staff know if you have any concerns or
suggestions on how MUCC can improve it services to our members and our
conservation work.
Ms. Stine’s written report follows:
First, I want to thank you for the honor of being your interim
Executive Director. I especially want to thank Don Meixner, members of the
Executive Board and the Board of Directors for their support, counsel and
partnership. Together, in four short months, we have re-energized this
organization, we have made tough, painful decisions, and we have addressed
difficult problems. It has been an exciting, challenging and productive four
months. I am proud that our members, board, executive board and staff have
fought through the negativity that was sinking this organization into
oblivion. The continued message of “ we can’t”, “it won’t work” , “your
wrong”, “we have never done it that way” is the fastest way to ensuring that
it will all come true, and “we can’t’ because we won’t exist. Today we will be
turning over to a new leader, an organization ready and able to fight the
significant problems that threaten the future of conservation.
Let’s take a moment to walk through our successes and by the
law there is a comprehensive list of our accomplishments on the handout table.
:
-
State Shoot is back! Detail on the handout table. It will
September 15 and 16 at Seaway Gun Club in Muskegon
-
We are working on five new fundraisers- 70th
Gun Raffle, Sporting Clays Fun Shoot, MUCC Golf Tournament and Life
member and new member sweepstakes. These will be in addition to our
Gun-a-month and calendar fundraisers
-
We have brought the conservation community back
together… Two meetings have produced an agenda for change.
-
We resolved the lottery issues allowing the clubs to
utilize charitable gaming for their conservation work.
-
We launched a new website.
-
We took 40 people to Washington to lobby for
Great Lakes Restoration. The good work of our members,
especially Elden Montross, Senator Levin agreed to introduce
federal legislation banning phosphorous in dishwasher detergent.
-
We received over $250,000 in grants.
-
We started a new member solicitation
-
We hosted over 300 people at our
70th Anniversary party where we had over
$10,000 in sponsors and $5500 in raffle earnings.
-
Over 80 members attended another
successful lobby day and earlier in the year we hosted
80 legislative staff for breakfast, helping us get to
know them and our policy priorities.
-
A shower building will be completed at
camp making it come closer to a year-around
facility.
-
We signed an agreement with ShowSpan
the largest outdoor show producer in the county to
produce Outdoorama, providing us with increased
revenue and exposure and minimizing our risks.
-
Tony Hansen and Jeannie Esch
totally redesigned the magazine leading to more
advertisers.
-
The largest yes vote in
Michigan’s history was recorded for Proposal
One. MUCC has constitutionally protected all of
the DNR’s restricted funds. A great legacy for
our 70th anniversary.
-
Our members understand the
importance of trapping as a wildlife
management tool and after hearing of a bill to
ban leg-hold traps immediately took to the
phones to stop the bill in its tracks.
-
Our great lakes are being
destroyed by invasive species. We have
forcefully told the shipping industry that
we want the discharge of ballast water to be
stopped. Our lawsuit supporting the new
Michigan ballast water permitting law sent a
very clear message that MUCC members are
serious about stopping the spread of
invasive species.
This is a small fraction of the forceful, positive and
productive accomplishments that have been achieved by our members and by staff
this year.
We obviously have much to build upon… we need this momentum,
these partnerships, and this passion to address the large issues facing
conservation and MUCC:
-
We are in serious trouble with conservation leadership in
the Michigan House of Representatives and in the Michigan Senate. When
Patty Birkholz leaves at the end of her term, we will have lost our
backstop for stopping bad legislation or working through conservation
needs. We must concentrate at the local level at reminding our elected
officials how important conservation is to us and that it is a voting
issue.
-
The state has disinvested in natural resources management
and environmental protection. Less than one penny, let me emphasize, one
penny from every dollar from the general fund in spent on DNR program. The
general fund support for the DNR has shrunk by 66% since 2000. DEQ has
lost 75% of their general fund since 2002. This year the state will spend
approximately $2.50 per Michigan resident for natural resource protect and
$3.30 per person for environmental protection from the state’s general
fund. Compare this to the $12.50 per person to support the legislature and
$187 per person to pay for our prison system. This disinvestment is penny
wise and pound foolish. For every dollar invested in conservation $116 is
returned. We must secure a long-term sustainable source of funding for
conservation. We have no money to manage our lands, monitor our waters,
restore our resources or manage our wildlife.
-
We must set aside our difference and begin to work together
for conservation. Our conflicts should be with those who wish to take away
our hunting and fishing rights, our hurt our environment. It should not be
with each other. We have started down that road of finding common ground
but this effort must be moved forward.
Speeches from the Statewide Vice President
Nominees:
Dawn Levey and Al Weaver
Emergency Resolution Announcement, Brenda Mortimer,
Chair
Withdrawn by maker of resolution, Chris Kettler in lieu of the
ShowSpan agreement
Pending Legislation
Marko (Finnerty) moved to consider under new business on
Sunday
Not considered an emergency, withdrawn and moved to the August
Board of Directors meeting
Please find below a list of resolutions passed by MUCC
Delegates at MUCC’s 2007 Annual Convention.
(Resolutions detailing legislative/regulation change required a
2/3 majority vote to pass per MUCC bylaws)
Resolution 03 – Clarification of Casing/Uncasing a Firearm from
a Vehicle
Resolution 04 – Use of Hunter Orange during Predator
Hunting
Resolution 08 – Reduction of Yellow Perch Limits
Resolution 09 – Darkhouse Angling
Resolution 11 – Lake Sturgeon License Requirement
Resolution 13 – Deer Baiting (Against)
Resolution 14 – Eurasian Milfoil Control on Inland Lakes and
Waterways
Resolution 15 – Michigan Department of Natural Resources
License Fee Package
Resolution 18 – Support for Nuclear Energy
Resolution 20 – Great Lakes Shipping
Resolution 21 – Funding the Management of Michigan’s Natural
Resources
Resolution 22 – Doe Permit Distribution
Resolution 23 – Lake St. Clair Pike Regulations
Resolution 24 – Protecting Michigan Hunting Heritage
Resolution 27 – Coyote Hunting in the Lower Peninsula (during
firearm deer season)
Resolution 29 – ORV Use on County Roads (Prohibit)
Resolution 03 – Clarification of Casing/Uncasing a
Firearm from a Vehicle
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that MUCC work with the Michigan
Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) and the Michigan Legislature to clarify
the regulation to allow casing or uncasing of a transported firearm when the
vehicle is stopped and the person is outside the vehicle.
Resolution 04 – Use of Hunter Orange During Predator
Hunting
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United Conservation
Clubs shall work with the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) and
the Natural Resources Commission (NRC) to allow the exemption of hunter orange
for predator hunting except during the Michigan firearm deer season.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that a person would be required to wear
an article of hunter orange clothing (per DNR regulations) while in transit
(up until seated).
Resolution 08 – Reduction of Yellow Perch
Limits
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the daily possession limit of
yellow perch on Brevort Lake, Mackinac County, Grand Lake (Presque Isle and
Alpena Counties) and Long Lake (Alpena Counties) be revised from fifty (50)
per person per day; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Michigan United Conservation
Clubs works with the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) to
establish a daily possession limit of thirty-five (35) per person, with a size
limit of seven (7) inches.
Resolution 09 – Darkhouse Angling
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) works with the Department of Natural Resources Fisheries Division
and Natural Resources Commission to extend the Darkhouse angling (spearing)
season to add the month of December and the first two weeks of March to the
existing January and February season.
Resolution 11 – Lake Sturgeon License
Requirement
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Sturgeon for Tomorrow, and
the Michigan United Conservation Clubs will work with and support the Michigan
Department of Natural Resources (MDNR), the National Resources Commission
(NRC), legislators, and other advocacy groups to support the passage of
legislation to require an all species license for fishing sturgeon.
Resolution 13 – Deer Baiting (Against)
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that MUCC is on record as opposing the
continued use of bait as a means of harvesting whitetail deer in
Michigan.
Resolution 14 – Eurasian Milfoil Control on Inland Lakes
and Waterways
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) work to develop a program similar to Maine’s that will create a
fund to be used to help treat Eurasian milfoil and other nuisance plants found
in Michigan’s public inland lakes and waterways; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that MUCC work to ensure that this
program also helps educate citizens about changing their behavior to help stop
the spread of nuisance plants and species in the State of Michigan.
Resolution 15 – Michigan Department of Natural Resources
License Fee Package
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) work with the Michigan Legislature to increase all license fees
to the amount needed to fund the Michigan Department of Natural Resources at
the 2005 budget level for a period of two (2) years; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that MUCC work with the Michigan
Legislature to find a permanent funding source for the MDNR that equally
spreads the burden of its funding for all citizens, as well as visitors to our
state.
Resolution 18 – Support for Nuclear Energy
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) encourage public acceptance of nuclear generation of electricity
as an environmentally-friendly alternative to fossil fuel generation; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that MUCC urge the National Wildlife
Federation (NWF) to reconsider the issue of nuclear energy as a part of a
comprehensive alternative energy policy initiative.
Resolution 20 – Great Lakes Shipping
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) work with the proper authorities to enact legislation preventing
sea-going vessels from entering the St. Lawrence Seaway without methods for
treating onboard ballast water; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that MUCC work with the proper
authorities to enact federal legislation and international treaties requiring
the treatment of ballast water in all Great Lakes vessels in order to prevent
the spread of invasive species; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED the MUCC work with the proper
authorities to enact federal legislation requiring an annual inspection of all
Great Lakes vessels to assure compliance with the treatment
requirement.
Resolution 21 – Funding the Management of Michigan’s
Natural Resources
THEREFORE IT BE RESOLVED, that the Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) work with the Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) and the
Natural Resources Commission (NRC) to develop, support, and work to get passed
a proposal that funds the management of Michigan’s natural resources in
perpetuity.
Resolution 22 – Doe Permit Distribution
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) urge the Natural Resource Commission (NRC) to change the doe
permit requirements.
Resolution 23 – Lake St. Clair Pike
Regulations
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United Conservation
Clubs work to get the pike limit reconsidered for Lake St. Clair back to five
(5) per day and the combination limit back to the 2002 mix.
Resolution 24 – Protecting Michigan Hunting
Heritage
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that MUCC initiate and take action to
inform the public on hunting, trapping, harvest ethics, actual game laws, and
the benefits of sustainable wildlife management due to hunting, fishing, and
trapping.
Resolution 27 – Coyote Hunting in the Lower Peninsula
(during firearm deer season)
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) support the taking of coyotes during the regular firearms deer
season in the Lower Peninsula as a necessary management tool for coyote
control; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that MUCC work to have the regulation
changed to meet that goal, provided it does not jeopardize federal delisting
of the gray wolf.
Resolution 29 – ORV Use on County Roads
(Prohibit)
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) opposes any change to Part 811 of the Natural Resources and
Environmental Protection Act that would authorize the use of ORVs on any
public land other than designated trails managed by the Michigan Department of
Natural Resources (DNR) between M-46 and the Mackinaw Bridge.
All 29 resolutions have been read, discussed and voted on –
they either failed as written or have been revised and carried as written.
Cullers (Kensinger) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 01 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 01
Submitted by: Mid County
Sportsmen’s Club and Menominee County Pheasant Club
Passed: February 3, 2007 – Region I
Title: Archery Deer Baiting
WHEREAS, bear hunters in Michigan can start baiting up to
thirty (30) days before bear season begins; and
WHEREAS, firearm deer hunters and muzzle-loading deer hunters
can, in effect, start baiting at least forty-five (45) days before their
season starts; and WHEREAS, archery deer hunters would like to begin baiting
before the start of archery season.
THEREORE BE IT RESOLVED that MUCC work with the Michigan
Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) to change the law to allow baiting
for archery deer hunting fifteen (15) days before the start of the archery
season.
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers does not support
the resolution
Vote on Resolution
Failed
Furtaw (Waters) asked for a motion to bring resolution No.
02 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION #
02
Submitted by: Upper Peninsula Bear Houndsmen Association
Passed: February 3, 2007 – Region I
Title: Charitable Gaming Raffle License
WHEREAS, in order to obtain a Raffle License with the State
of Michigan it is necessary to meet the requirements of the Gaming
Commission; and WHEREAS the way the law reads now without the amendment,
clubs that are service organizations, that were formerly covered under MUCC
are no longer eligible for a raffle license; and
WHEREAS, it states that we have to be a fraternal or civic
organization; and WHEREAS, all the sportsmen’s clubs that do not have
Chapters or Regions are not eligible, including UPBHA (Upper Peninsula Bear
Houndsmen Association); and
WHEREAS, the clubs that are affiliates of MUCC, support the
house bill
# 4188 and without raffle licenses will no longer be able to
support MUCC financially.
THEREFORE BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that on this day, MUCC and
its affiliates support the amendment to HB #4188 to protect our right to
obtain a State of Michigan Raffle License as service organizations.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion: none
Vote on Resolution
Failed
Marko (Cullers) asked for a motion to bring resolution No.
03 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION #
03
Submitted by: Mid County Sportsmen’s Club and Menominee
County Pheasants Club
Passed: February 3, 2007 – Region I
Title: Clarification of Casing or Uncasing a Firearm from
a Vehicle
WHEREAS, current Michigan regulation under Section 324.40111
has been interpreted by law enforcement agencies to prohibit casing or
uncasing a firearm while any part of the firearm is in contact with the
vehicle or is physically within the confines of the vehicle even though a
person is outside of the vehicle with both feet on the ground; and
WHEREAS, the intent of the law appears to require a cased
firearm (fully zipped) for transportation purposes only and is not related
to uncasing the firearm when the vehicle is stopped and the person is
outside the vehicle with both feet on the ground.
THEREFORE BE RESOLVED that MUCC work with the Michigan
Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) and the Michigan Legislature to
clarify the regulation to allow casing or uncasing of a transported firearm
when the vehicle is stopped and the person is outside the vehicle.
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers supports the
resolution; Jack Lehto, comments; Bruce Levey, clarification; Art Dittmar,
comments
Vote on Resolution
Carried (re-affirmed position that was took at 2006
convention)
Lehto (Lindquist) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 04 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION #
04
Submitted by: Ottawa Sportsmen’s Club
Passed: February 3, 2007 – Region I
Title: Use of Hunter Orange While Predator
Hunting
WHEREAS, several types of Michigan hunting such as archery
deer, waterfowl, crow, and turkey do not require wearing of hunter orange to
allow full use of camouflage and concealment; and
WHEREAS, current Michigan hunting regulations do not exempt
predator hunters from use of hunter orange, even though predator hunting is
allowed between sunset and sunrise; and
WHEREAS, camouflage and concealment is desirable while
hunting predators.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United
Conservation
Clubs work with the Michigan Department of Natural Resources
(MDNR)
and the Natural Resources Commission (NRC) to allow the
exemption of
hunter orange for predator hunting except during the Michigan
firearm deer
season.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED; a person would be required to
wear an article of hunter orange clothing (per DNR regulations) while in
transit (up until seated).
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers supports the
resolution with insertion of staff comment on line #8
Vote on Amendment
Carried
Discussion:
Emil Silarski on behalf of Hunter Education, supports; Jim
DeClerk, comments
Vote on Resolution as Amended
Carried
Lehto (Kensinger) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 05 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION #
05
Submitted by: Ottawa Sportsmen’s Club
Passed: February 3, 2007 – Region I
Title: Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR)
Sampling Survey Allocations
WHEREAS, the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR)
has issued surveys on a sampling basis to solicit public opinion on various
game management and land management issues, and
WHEREAS, the residents of the area being considered for
change are most likely to be impacted by any changes in management policy.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United
Conservation
Clubs will work to assure that the MDNR sampling surveys not
less than
fifty percent (50%) of the surveys sent out be to residents
of the area that the
proposed management change would impact.
Discussion:
Jack Lehto (maker of resolution), comments; Jason Dinsmore
(staff), explained why staff opposed the resolution; George Lindquist,
supports
Vote on Resolution
Failed
Marko (Colegrove) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 06 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION #
06
Submitted by: Straits Area Sportsmen’s Club
Passed: February 3, 2007 – Region I
Title: License Increase
WHEREAS, the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR)
has proposed an increase in hunting and fishing licenses; and
WHEREAS, if the MDNR does not increase license fees there
will be a forty (40) million dollar deficit by year 2010; and
WHEREAS, Michigan has a tremendous amount of public land and
water resources that require a huge responsibility to maintain them; and
WHEREAS, the water and land resources of Michigan are there for all the
people of Michigan and the visitors that vacation here to enjoy; and
WHEREAS, a 1/10th of 1% (.1%) increase in the Michigan state
sales tax would raise approximately one-hundred (100) million dollars, which
would add about ten ($10) to forty ($40) per year per family, and this
increase would also be paid by all the visitors of Michigan and if passed
there would be no need to raise licenses; and
WHEREAS, the new money raised by the increase would be
protected by Proposal One (1) that was voted into law in November 2006.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United
Conservation Clubs (MUCC) work with the Michigan Legislators to add a
1/10th of 1% (.1%) increase to the Michigan state sales tax for
funding of the MDNR; and BE IT YET FURTHER RESOLVED that MUCC work with the
Michigan Legislators to increase the current funding of the MDNR General
Fund.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers made no stand on
the resolution; Donna Stine, comments on the current work with the DNR on
long-term funding; Jim Maturn, supports
Vote on Resolution
Failed
Clyde Thorn (maker of resolution) withdrew resolution.
PROPOSED RESOLUTION #
07
Submitted by: Mid County Sportsmen’s Club and Menominee
County Pheasant Club
Passed: February 3, 2007 – Region I
Title: One Buck Rule for the Upper Peninsula
WHEREAS, in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula the population of
mature, 2 ½ year and older whitetail deer bucks are at a critically low
level; and
WHEREAS, the most mating currently occurring is with immature
bucks is resulting in late spring, early summer fawn drops by the doe, with
an increased mortality rate from predators; and
WHEREAS, late fawn drops result in smaller deer when winter
arrives, again with higher mortality rates in the Upper Peninsula due to
severe winters and predators; and
WHEREAS, with a one buck rule, many hunters will be passing
up opportunities to shoot an immature or “spike” buck early in the season;
and WHEREAS, hunters wishing to shoot mature bucks will have their chances
increased.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United
Conservation Clubs (MUCC) work with the Natural Resource Commission (NRC)
and the Michigan Legislature to designate a one buck per-year per-hunter
rule for the Upper Peninsula.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Colegrove (Waters) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 08 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION #
08
Submitted by: Straits Area Sportsmen’s Club
Passed: February 3, 2007 – Region I
Title: Reduction in Yellow Perch Limits (Brevort Lake)
WHEREAS, the perch fishery in Brevort Lake, Mackinac County
has significantly diminished over the past thirty (30) years prior to the
initiation of a cormorant harassment program; and
WHEREAS, the perch fishery has improved over the past several
years due to the initiation of a cormorant harassment program on Brevort
Lake; and WHEREAS, the improved perch fishery has induced extreme fishing
pressure on Brevort Lake; and
WHEREAS, the perch fishery on Brevort Lake is in a stage of
recovery; and WHEREAS, it is prudent to protect that recovery from over
fishing; and WHEREAS, it is also deemed prudent to conserve the stock of
spawning size fish.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the daily/possession limit of
yellow perch on Brevort Lake, Mackinac County, Grand Lake (Presque
Isle and Alpena Counties) and Long Lake (Alpena Counties) be revised
from fifty (50) per person per day; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Michigan United Conservation
Clubs work with the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) to
establish a thirty-five (35) per person per day with a size limit of seven
(7) inches.
Discussion:
Gary Hagen, opposed, Bruce Levey as parliamentarian, reported
a change of rules and that this resolution required a 2/3 vote, Cullers,
supports
Vote on Amendment to add the rule
Carried
Vote on Resolution as Amended
Carried
Lindquist (Furtaw) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 09 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION #
09
Submitted by: Mid Michigan Sportsmen’s Club and the Menominee
County Pheasant Club
Passed: February 3, 2007 – Region I
Title: Darkhouse Angling (Spearing)
WHEREAS, Darkhouse angling is very popular in Michigan,
especially in the northern regions where ice forms early; and
WHEREAS, the current open season for Darkhouse angling
(spearing) is January and February, it would seem reasonable to allow for
more Darkhouse angling opportunities to include the month of December and
the first two weeks of March; and
WHEREAS, Darkhouse angling has a significant historical
history to Michigan, having the first recorded incidence of spearing through
the ice using a fish decoy; and
WHEREAS, Darkhouse angling is a legal, angling method to
harvest northern pike and musky, and
WHREREAS, extending the spearing season for northern pike and
musky to add the month of December and the first two weeks of March in
Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) Regions I and II would
extend angling opportunities for Darkhouse anglers.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United
Conservation Clubs (MUCC) works with the Department of Natural Resources
Fisheries Division and Natural Resources Commission to extend the Darkhouse
angling (spearing) season to add the month of December and the first two
weeks of March to the exiting January and February season.
Discussion:
George Lindquist asked for clarification of what weeks within
the month are for consideration; Maker of the resolution, explained
Vote on Resolution
Carried
Lehto (Kensinger) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 10 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 10
Submitted by: Mid County Sportsmen’s Club, Menominee County
Pheasant Club, and the Ottawa Sportsmen’s Club
Passed: February 3, 2007 – Region I
Title: Crossbow as an Option During Archery Deer
Season
WHEREAS, many Michigan’s neighbor states allow the use of a
crossbow during their archery season; and
WHEREAS, the option of using a crossbow would provide
opportunity to hunt for a number of people who would not otherwise be able
to hunt with traditional bows; and
WHEREAS, Michigan United Conservation Clubs (MUCC) and
sportsmen’s groups should encourage as much participation as possible in
hunting.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that MUCC work with the Natural
Resource Commission and the Michigan Legislature to allow use of crossbows
during the regular archery deer season.
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers opposed the
resolution; Bruce Levey, opposed; Jack Lehto, supports; Past President Wendy
Briggs, supports; Jerry Keck, opposed; Chuck Murphy, supports; George
Cullers, supports, Gordon Bickle Jr., opposed; Fred Tyska, supports; Will
Van Ander, opposed; Lee Winn, supports; George Randall, offered amendment to
add “for qualified disabled hunters and those sixty-five (65) and over”;
Vote on Amendment
Failed
Discussion continued:
Bruce Levey, opposed; Wendy Briggs, supports; Dawn Levey,
neutral however, concerned on the title “senior”; Dave Borgeson, opposed;
Mike Borst, offered amendment to add “limited”; Mike Kensinger, supports
amendment; Bruce Levey, asked for explanation to the word “limited”; Mike
Borst, explained
Vote on Amendment
Card vote called by Dave Smith Yes: 168 No: 211
Failed
Vote on resolution
Card vote called by Eldon Montross Yes: 159 No:
186
Failed
Supina (Demos) asked for a motion to bring resolution No.
11 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 11
Submitted by: Sturgeon for Tomorrow
Passed: February 4, 2007 – Region II
Title: Lake Sturgeon License Requirement
WHEREAS, the Lake Sturgeon is a member of an ancient family
of fish that existed one hundred thirty six (136) million years ago and is
the largest freshwater fish in the Great Lakes basin and is considered a
desirable trophy fish; and
WHEREAS, Lake Sturgeon populations have significantly
declined across much of their range partly due to hydropower dams that
limited the available spawning habitat; and
WHEREAS, there is a Lake Sturgeon rehabilitation plan that
includes efforts to rehabilitate and re-establish self-sustaining
populations of Lake Sturgeon; and
WHEREAS, there are viable populations of Lake Sturgeon in
areas of Michigan which support hook and line harvest or a limited spearing
season; and
WHEREAS, licenses to spear Lake Sturgeon are tightly
controlled and available only through an application and lottery process;
and
WHEREAS, locking harvest tags are required to fish by hook
and line for Lake Sturgeon in other bodies of water in Michigan; and
WHEREAS, successful anglers must tag their fish and register
the fish immediately at a designated registration station.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Sturgeon Tomorrow, and the
Michigan United Conservation Clubs will work with and support the Michigan
Department of Natural Resources (MDNR), the National Resources Commission
(NRC), legislators, and other advocacy groups to support the passage of
legislation to require an all species license for fishing sturgeon.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion:
None
Vote on Resolution
Carried Unanimously
Smith (Finnerty) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 12 to the floor for consideration
Clyde Thorn (maker of resolution No. 12) withdrew
resolution
Substitute resolution inserted.
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 12
Submitted by: Dave Smith, DFR, District 13
Passed: February 4, 2007 – Region II
Title: One Buck per Calendar Year
WHEREAS, the State of Michigan traditionally allowed each
deer hunter to harvest one buck per calendar season, tagging it with either
an archery tag or a firearm tag; and
WHEREAS, the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR)
conceived of another way to capitalize on the Whitetail resource by selling
more buck tags to each hunter (some years as many as four (4) buck tags per
hunter); and
WHEREAS, in the view of many hunters, this capitalization of
the resource was not necessarily what was best for the resource and was
probably not “scientific game management” of the resource; and
WHEREAS, the second buck of the season, what an older hunter
might tag, could be denying a younger hunter their opportunity at a first
buck of the season; and
WHEREAS, the MDNR itself has shown signs of moving in the
direction of Quality Deer Management (QDM), which would probably favor a
higher “buck to doe” ratio than what currently exist in the State of
Michigan.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United
Conservation Clubs (MUCC) works with the MDNR to return Michigan to a
harvest rule of one whitetail buck per calendar season per hunter to be
harvested with either archery equipment or firearms.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers supports the
resolution; George Lindquist, offered an amendment to line 28; Cullers,
supports; Dave Borgeson, asked for clarification of the word “tagging”;
Norma Hayes-Walkley, clarification on whom handles and assesses fines; John
Cischke, DNR Wildlife Division, explained the pattern that is currently
practiced by law enforcement officers; Mr. Cischke also expressed that the
act would need to be amended; Jason Dinsmore of staff, clarified what tags
to use in the event of a kill with less than the required points
Gary Modlin recommended an amendment, to the amendment, by
adding “a secondary tag”; Bill Furtaw, opposed; Tom Heritier, expressed that
hunters should be aware of what they have in their sites before shooting;
Dave Smith, mentioned that “honest” mistakes should be considered;
Vote on Amendment to the 1st Amendment
Failed
Vote on 1st Amendment
Failed
Discussion continued:
Dave Smith, supports; Jim DeClerk asked for clarification;
George Lindquist, supports; Steve Bartz, opposed; Jerry Keck, opposed; Gary
Modlin, supports
Vote on Resolution
Failed
Smith (Hagen) asked for a motion to bring resolution No.
13 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 13
Submitted by: Dave Smith, DFR, District 13
Passed: February 4, 2007 – Region II
Title: Deer Baiting
WHEREAS, the Michigan United Conservation Clubs (MUCC) passed
a resolution at its 2000 annual convention asking for a complete ban on the
practice of deer baiting and feeding in the lower peninsula – effectively
putting MUCC on record as opposing deer feeding and baiting in the Lower
Peninsula; and
WHEREAS, since this resolution passed in 2000, the state of
Wisconsin has discovered Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD) in its free ranging
whitetail herd; and
WHEREAS, Michigan’s Upper Peninsula (UP) shares a border with
Wisconsin and a deer wandering Wisconsin’s forest today may be found in the
Upper Peninsula tomorrow; and
WHEREAS, baiting limits enacted by the Michigan Department of
Natural Resources (MDNR) are impossible to enforce with the violation rate
being high throughout the state; and
WHEREAS, bait stations become gathering spots that help
facilitate the transmission of communicable diseases, such as Bovine
Tuberculosis and CWD.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that MUCC be on record as opposing
the continued use of bait as a means of harvesting whitetail in
Michigan.
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers supports the
resolution; Dave Smith, supports; Jack Lehto, opposed; Steve Bartz,
supports; Dave Borgeson, supports
Vote on Resolution
Carried
J. Meixner (Demos) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 14 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 14
Submitted by: Dave Foley and Al Anderson representing the
Lake Mitchell Improvement Board and Lake Mitchell Association of Cadillac,
Michigan
Passed: February 4, 2007 – Region II
Title: Eurasian Milfoil Control on Inland Lakes and
Waterways
WHEREAS, the recent appearance of great quantities of
Eurasian milfoil in our lakes clogs swimming areas, impedes boat navigation,
and the dominance of Eurasian milfoil causes decline in natural plants as
well as covering habitat favored by perch, walleye, and smallmouth bass; and
WHEREAS, this discourages tourists and vacationers from using
these lakes, which causes local economies to suffer; and
WHEREAS, presence of Eurasian milfoil causes a decrease in
property values, which results in lost tax revenues; and
WHEREAS, the tremendous annual expense to chemically treat
and/or purchase milfoil-eating weevils is almost totally borne by lakeshore
property owners even though the lakes are used by all of Michigan’s
residents; and WHEREAS, virtually all public monies dedicated to treating
invasive species are allocated to dealing with the problems in the Great
Lakes, and do not address inland lakes; and
WHEREAS, the state of Maine has a program where residents pay
an annual ten dollar ($10.00) fee and non-residents pay a twenty dollar
($20.00) fee for all motorized boats, launched in that state’s waters with
proceeds used in the treatment of Eurasian milfoil and other invasive
species.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) work to develop a program similar to Maine’s that will create a
fund to be used to help treat Eurasian milfoil and other nuisance plants
found in Michigan’s public inland lakes and waterways; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that MUCC work to ensure that this
program also helps educated citizens about changing their behavior to help
stop the spread of nuisance plants and species in the State of
Michigan.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion:
Tom Hamilton, supports resolution however, he is concerned
about the chemical effects; Bob Laich, opposed; Jim Maturn, requested an
amendment to specify non-chemical treatment; Dave Borgeson, opposed; George
Randal, opposed; Greg Peter, supports; Jane Finnerty, on behalf on the maker
of the resolution, supports
Vote on Resolution
Carried
Cullers (Kensinger) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 15 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 15
Submitted by: Big Bear Sportsman’s Club
Passed: February 4, 2007 – Region II
Title: Michigan Department of Natural Resources License
Fee Increase
WHEREAS, hunting and fishing licenses are being proposed for
increases; and
WHEREAS, this will result in greater financial cost for all
hunters and anglers who are already struggling in a poor economy; and
WHEREAS, there is a possibility that some hunters and anglers
will be unable to pay increased fees, but will continue to hunt and fish
without a license, resulting in a loss of revenue for the Michigan
Department of Natural Resources and more problems for conservation officers;
and WHEREAS, fewer licenses result in lower Pittman-Robinson funds being
returned to Michigan and less revenue generated by license sales; and
WHEREAS, our clubs are strongly involved in introducing youngsters to
hunting and angling, and the financial burden of higher fees could result in
parents being unable to pay these increases; and
WHEREAS, seniors are facing higher taxes as well as increases
in food, fuel, and medical care costs and many of these seniors have paid
full license fees for fifty years and more; and
WHEREAS, hunters and anglers donate thousands of hours to
Hunter Education classes and are involving more men, women, and children in
outdoor pursuits.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) work with the Michigan Legislature to increase all license fees
to the amount needed to fund the Michigan Department of Natural Resources at
the 2005 budget level for a period of two (2) years; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that MUCC work with the Michigan
Legislature to find a permanent funding source for the MDNR that equally
spreads the burden of it’s funding for all citizens as well as visitors to
our state.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers supports the
resolution; Bob Borchak, asked for clarification; Jane Finnerty, clarified
(2-yrs);
Vote on Resolution
Carried
Cullers (J. Meixner) asked for a motion to bring
resolution No. 16 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 16
Submitted by: Bill Knapp, Northland Sportsmen’s Club
Passed: February 4, 2007 – Region II
Title: Primitive Hunting Season
WHEREAS, the muzzle loading season has evolved from it’s
original intent of a traditional side lock black powder season, into an
extension of the regular deer season with the advent of modern
muzzleloaders, which are now center fire front loading modern rifles, with
the same range and accuracy as regular deer season guns; and
WHEREAS, the muzzle loading season was created for fair chase
using a more primitive gun, with it’s inherit challenges of iron sights,
limited range, and need for more skill in the stalking game.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan Department of
Natural Resources (MDNR) creates a PRIMITIVE WEAPONS SEASON in addition to
any muzzle loading season that limits the type of weapon used to take deer.
Weapons would be side lock muzzleloaders with iron or peep sights, using
round ball only (flintlock, and percussion), long bows, or recurve bows
(using wood arrows). This would provide Michigan hunters the same
opportunity that is offered in other States. As a separate but equal season,
this would also create additional revenues for the Michigan Department of
Natural Resources.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers supports the
resolution; Dave Borgeson, opposed; Steve Bartz, opposed;
Vote on Resolution
Failed
J. Meixner (Kensinger) asked for a motion to bring
resolution No. 17 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 17
Submitted by: Glenn Fobel, Hillsdale County Conservation
Club
Passed: February 17, 2007 - Region 3
Title: Changing All Fish and Game Season Opening Days to
Saturday
WHEREAS, businesses such as hotels, motels, restaurants,
state parks, sporting good shops, gas stations and more are dependant on the
income derived from Michigan’s sportsmen and women; and
WHEREAS, having the opening day of a game season during the
week rather than on Saturday or Sunday is counter productive to Michigan’s
businesses because many people have to work during the week and are
therefore unable to spend the dollars that sportsmen and women contribute to
the economy during fish and game seasons; and
WHEREAS, getting youth involved in the outdoors is critically
important to the future of hunting, fishing, and trapping in Michigan and
when opening day begins on a weekday, fewer youth are able to participate
because of school; and
WHEREAS, more people participate in a Saturday opener than an
opener during the week and more participants means more money spent on fish
and game licenses and more dollars contributed to Michigan’s
businesses.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that MUCC work with the Michigan
Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) to change the opening day of all fish
and game seasons to the Saturday closest to the current opening date.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers opposed the
resolution; Julia Meixner, supports; Bud Slingerlend, opposed; Bruce Levey,
on behalf of the Michigan Bowhunters, opposed; Art Dittmar, questioned the
opening of the season, which runs several months with the exception of bass
season which opens the last Saturday of the month, opposed;
Vote on Resolution
Failed
Kensinger (Cullers) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 18 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 18
Submitted by: Gregory K. Peter MS, DVM, DACLAM
Comparative Medicine - Ann Arbor,
Michigan
Passed: February 17, 2007 - Region 3
Title: Support for Nuclear Energy
Whereas, the United States has operated one hundred and three
(103) nuclear generation plants for over forty (40) years without serious
injury to anyone; and
Whereas, all large U.S. Navy ships and over one hundred (100)
nuclear submarines have used nuclear power for over forty (40) years with no
incidents; and
Whereas, the French generate eight percent (80%) of their
electricity with nuclear powered plants without problems; and
Whereas, the French recycle spent fuel rods so that when they
are disposed of their radioactive half life is measured in decades not the
ten-thousand (10,000) years that is currently the practice in the United
States; and
Whereas, the United States is capable of using the French
technology to dispose of our nuclear waste; and
Whereas, research and development of new nuclear generations
have continued with safety as a primary consideration. New modular units as
small as one-hundred (100) megawatts have been designed and could be located
near areas with immediate need for electrical energy.
THEREFORE Be it resolved that the Michigan United
Conservation Clubs (MUCC) would encourage public acceptance of nuclear
generation of electricity as an environmentally-friendly alternative to
fossil fuel generation.
and be it YET further resolved that MUCC instruct its
delegate to the National Wildlife Federation (NWF) to have such a policy
adopted at the national meeting and that NWF should lobby at the Federal
level to have regulations/legislations promulgated which would encourage the
energy industry to build new nuclear plants urge the National
Wildlife Federation (NWF) to reconsider the issue of nuclear energy as a
part of a comprehensive alternative energy policy initiative.
This resolution requires new legislation and will
require a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion:
Paul Rose offered substitute language as follows:
…”That MUCC urge the National Wildlife Federation (NWF) to
reconsider the issue of nuclear energy as a part of a comprehensive
alternative energy policy initiative.”
Bruce Levey, supports language; George Lindquist, opposed;
Dave Borgeson, supports; Greg Peter, maker of resolution supports; John
Wiske, supports; Jerry Keck, supports;
Vote on Resolution
Carried
Resolution No. 19 – withdrawn by maker
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 19
Submitted by: District 10
Passed: February 18, 2007 – Region 4
Title: Fall Turkey Season
WHEREAS, the fall turkey season licenses are not sold out;
and WHEREAS, the fall turkey season coincides with the early deer archery
season thus creating a deterrent from turkey hunting; and
WHEREAS, expansion of the fall turkey season will not
unfavorably impact the population but will allow more field time.
THEREFORE Be it resolved, that Michigan United Conservation
Clubs request the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) and the
Natural Resources Commission (NRC) to consider changing the fall turkey
season to September 1 through December 31 each year, to exclude the regular
firearm deer season November 15 though November 30 each year.
Norma Hays-Walkley (Montross) asked for a motion to bring
resolution No. 20 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 20
Submitted by: District 10
Passed: February 18, 2007 – Region IV
Title: Great Lakes Shipping
WHEREAS, allowing sea going ships to enter the St. Lawrence
Seaway has been the main cause of invasive species being introduced into the
Great Lakes; and
WHEREAS, these invasive species have, in a number of cases,
spread to the inland waters of Michigan; and
WHEREAS, the introduction of invasive species is occurring at
an alarming rate; and
WHEREAS, the cost of controlling theses invasive species is
far greater than the economic value contributed by allowing sea going
vessels into the Great Lakes; and
WHEREAS, these invasive species have a detrimental impact on
the economy of the state of Michigan as well as the other Great Lake states.
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that Michigan United Conservation
Clubs (MUCC) work with the proper authorities to enact legislation
preventing sea going vessels from entering the St. Lawrence Seaway
without methods for treating onboard ballast water; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that MUCC work with the proper
authorities to enact federal legislation and international treaties
requiring treatment of ballast water in all Great Lake vessels in order to
prevent the spread of invasive species; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED the MUCC work with the proper
authorities to enact federal legislation requiring an annual inspection of
all Great Lakes vessels to assure compliance with the treatment
requirement.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers supports the
resolution with an amendment to line #12; Bruce Levey, supports amendment;
Vote on Amendment
Carried
Vote on Resolution
Carried
Marko (Waters) asked for a motion to bring resolution No.
21 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 21
Submitted by: District 10
Passed: February 18, 2007 – Region IV
Title: Funding the Management of Michigan’s Natural
Resources
WHEREAS, the people of the state of Michigan hold dear its
natural resources – its air, soil, and mineral, its forests, waters, and
wildlife; and WHEREAS, the natural resources of the state of Michigan offer
its citizens a unique opportunity to observe, partake, and participate in
the workings of the natural world; and
WHEREAS, the natural resources of the state of Michigan
require highly educated and trained managers in order to be maintained at
the level desired by the people of the state of Michigan; and
WHEREAS, the economic impact to the state of Michigan due to
direct or indirect use if of its natural resources is in excess of fifty
(50) billion with a large sum of that amount being spent in the more
economically depressed areas of the state; and
WHEREAS, the contribution of that economic impact to the
state of Michigan’s general fund is ten (10) or more times greater than the
general fund contribution to the management of Michigan’s natural resources;
and WHEREAS, the sportspersons of the state of Michigan have been the major
supporters of the management of Michigan’s natural resources for many years;
and
WHEREAS, the natural resources of the state of Michigan are
enjoyed and used by all the people of the state of Michigan; and
WHEREAS, the funding of the management of the natural
resources of the state of Michigan should be supported by all the people
enjoying and using the natural resources of the state of Michigan whether a
resident or a visitor.
THEREFORE IT BE RESOLVED, that the Michigan United
Conservation Clubs (MUCC) work with the Department of Natural Resources
(MDNR) and the Natural Resources Commission (NRC) to develop, support and
work to get passed a ballot proposal that funds the
management of Michigan’s natural resources in perpetuity.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion:
Bud Slingerlend asked for clarification on the word
“billions”; Jim DeClerk, reported the various places the “billions” fund
such as hunting, fishing, boating, gas, etc…; On behalf of the Wildlife
Committee, Cullers made no stand on the resolution; Donna Stine staff,
opposed, Tom Gregory asked for an amendment to remove the word “ballot”;
Steve Bartz, supports;
Vote on Amendment
Carried
Discussion continued:
Jack Lehto, opposed; Jim DeClerk, supports (clarification on
the word “ballot”); Steve Bartz, supports; Bob Brethan, opposed;
Vote on Resolution
Carried
Donna Stine explained that currently there are other
organizations like MUCC that would like to see it made more difficult to put
something on the ballot. This would make it more difficult for the antis to
come into the state with issues to place on the ballot.
Kensinger (Cullers) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 22 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 22
Submitted by: Fred Tyszka, District 7
Passed: February 18, 2007 – Region IV
Title: Doe Permit Distribution
(Draft)
WHEREAS, the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR)
attempts to control the Michigan deer herd at sustainable levels for their
environs; and
WHEREAS, one of the acceptable biological tolls used for the
deer herd control is the issuing of doe kill permits; and
WHEREAS, the minimum acreage for portions of Michigan were
set at a forty (40) acre minimum and requiring the landowner’s telephone
number; and
WHEREAS, no limits where set on the number of applicants per
forty (40) or more acres; and
WHEREAS, many sportsmen who owned or had access to less then
forty (40) acres were excluded from this process; and
WHEREAS, the deer problem does not exist only on the plots of
forty (40) or more acres; and
WHEREAS, these less then forty (40) acres property owners
also pay land taxes and purchase the same sportsmen license of which the
funds or fees from these transactions also support the Michigan Department
of Natural Resources (MDNR) programs; and
WHEREAS, the majority of the population can no longer afford
to purchase large tracts of land nor afford leasing or being able to acquire
access to these forty (40) plus acre properties; and
WHEREAS, the large acreage in many parts of the state are
being divided into smaller tracts for greater profits; and
WHEREAS, a lower acreage requirement is allowable in other
parts of the state, now
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the Michigan United
Conservation Clubs (MUCC) urge that the Natural Resource Commission (NRC) to
change the doe permit requirements.
Discussion:
On behalf of the Wildlife Committee, Cullers opposed the
resolution; Fred Tyska, maker of the resolution amended the resolution by
removing the word “draft” in the title.
Vote on Resolution
Call on card vote by SWVP. Bill Krepps Yes: 208 No:
107
Carried
Furtaw (Dittmar) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 23 to the floor for consideration
PROPOSED RESOLUTION # 23
Submitted by: Bill Furtaw, Chairman, District 8
Passed: February 18, 2007 - Region IV
Title: Lake St. Clair Pike Regulation
WHEREAS, there are no shortage of big or small pike in Lake
St. Clair; and WHEREAS, Lake St. Clair has more pike than it needs to
balance the Lake’s fish species; and
WHEREAS, there are too many predator fish (pike, muskies,
bass, and walleye) in Lake St. Clair; and
WHEREAS, pike, muskies, or bass are “catch and release” in
Lake St. Clair because most are fishing for big fish; and
WHEREAS, the Michigan Department of Natural Resources does
not plant fish in Lake St. Clair because the populations reproduce
naturally; and
WHEREAS, pike, muskie, bass, and walleye feed on perch; and
WHEREAS, people enjoy catching and eating perch from Lake St.
Clair; and WHEREAS, perch have too many predators in Lake St. Clair,
including man; and
WHEREAS, fishermen catch and release pike, and keep the
walleyes to fill the combination bag limit; and
WHEREAS, fishermen will eat walleye but not pike; and
WHEREAS, the MDNR appears to be managing Lake St. Clair fish
populations for trophy muskie, bass, and pike; and
WHEREAS, inland fishing regulations should not be applied to
Lake St. Clair; and
WHEREAS, the two (2) pike per day limit is in the wrong for
Lake St. Clair, now
THEREFORE Be it resolved, the Michigan United Conservation
Clubs work to get the pike limit reconsidered for Lake St. Clair back to
five (5) per day and the combination limit back to the 2002 mix.
This resolution requires new legislation and will require
a 2/3-majority vote to pass.
Discussion:
Art Dittmar talked about the comments recently made by the
NRC (Natural Resource Commission); Bruce Levey, acting as parliamentarian
explained the need for a 2/3 vote on this resolution;
Vote on Resolution
Carried
President Meixner (Kensinger) asked for a motion to
adjourn general session for the day.
Carried
Pachy (D. Levey) asked for a motion to bring resolution
No. 24 to the floor for consideration
|